Articles

Bid, Negotiated, or Design-Assist: Three Ways to Hire a General Contractor

By Structures and Interiors.

There are three common ways for a practice owner to hire a general contractor. S&I builds under all three, so we have no reason to push you toward one. The right choice depends on how firm your budget is, how far along your drawings are, and how much of your own time you can give the project. For the wider question of who to hire, see our guide on choosing a medical office contractor.

Competitive bid

Your architect finishes the drawings. Several contractors price the same set, and you choose among the numbers. This is also called design-bid-build or hard bid.

  • What you get. Market pricing from several contractors on one set of drawings, and a fixed price before construction starts.
  • What you give up. Pricing arrives late, after the design decisions are made. If the low bid is over budget, the fix is to cut the design, which is the process we describe in value engineering. The contractor also has no voice in the design, and a low number often reflects what was left out of the drawings.
  • Pricing and contingency. Each bidder gives a price for the work shown. Anything the drawings do not show, or show differently in two places, is where change orders come from. Bid work is almost always a stipulated sum: one fixed price for the work in the drawings. We do not carry contingency as a line item in our price. Instead, we recommend that you hold your own contingency for those gaps, and for what is found behind walls and above ceilings in existing space, and we can suggest a percentage or range based on common rules of thumb for your kind of project.
  • When it fits. The design is complete, the budget has room, and you want to see competing numbers before you sign.

Negotiated

You choose the contractor early, based on qualifications, references, and fee. The contractor then prices the design as it develops, and you work through the numbers together.

  • What you get. Budget control during design, and subcontractor bids that are shared with you. You know the contractor before the drawings are done.
  • What you give up. The head-to-head number. You are trusting the qualifications and the open pricing in place of a competing bid.
  • Pricing and contingency. The price is built with you as the drawings firm up, so you see where the money goes. It ends as one of two contracts: a stipulated sum (one fixed price), or cost plus a fee with a guaranteed maximum price, where you pay actual cost plus the fee up to a ceiling. On a guaranteed maximum price, savings under the ceiling are typically split between you and the contractor. Either way, the contingency is yours to hold, and we can suggest how much.
  • When it fits. The schedule is tight, the project is complex, or you would rather pick a team on trust than on the lowest bid.

Design-assist

You hire the architect, and we join while the architect designs. We price the work as the design develops and advise on systems and constructability, so the budget and the drawings stay in step.

We did this on GI Alliance Waco Endoscopy Center and Clinic, a one-story, 13,344-square-foot endoscopy center and clinic for the developer MedCore Partners, with Corgan as architect. We worked design-assist with Corgan, construction took 11 months, and the building was finished in summer 2024.

  • What you get. Pricing feedback while changes are still cheap. If a choice is over budget, you hear it before it is drawn. The architect, the engineers, and the builder work as one team.
  • What you give up. You commit to a contractor before the full set is priced, and you will not see competing numbers on the whole building. Your own time matters more, because you are making decisions during design instead of after it.
  • Pricing and contingency. Price comes in stages: early budgets that sharpen as the drawings do, then a final contract, either a stipulated sum or cost plus a fee with a guaranteed maximum price, as with negotiated work. Your contingency is easiest to size here, because the open items are known and listed as the design settles.
  • When it fits. The budget is firm, the building is complex, or the interior drives the shell. A medical interior sets roof unit sizes, plumbing under the slab, electrical service, and ceiling heights, so early pricing tends to pay off. Our guide to shell and finish-out in one contract goes further.

Negotiated or design-assist: what is the difference?

The two overlap, but they are not the same. Negotiated describes how you choose the contractor and agree on the price: on qualifications and open pricing, not on the lowest of several bids. A design-assist contractor is often chosen that way too, but not always: some owners ask several contractors to bid their fee and present their qualifications, then pick one to join the design team. Design-assist describes how early and how deeply the contractor works with your design team. On a negotiated job, we may come in with the drawings well along and price what is drawn. On a design-assist job, we are at the table while the architect and engineers make the decisions, pricing options and advising on systems before they are drawn.

Why we do not do design-build

In design-build, one company holds the contract for both design and construction, and the architect works for the contractor. We do not offer that. We work with your architect, so the architect works for you.

That keeps one more set of eyes on our work: the architect reviews what we build against the drawings and answers to you. If design-build appeals to you because you want one team, early pricing, and a builder at the table from the start, design-assist gives you nearly the same thing. The contractor and the architect work together from early design, you see cost as the drawings develop, and the architect still answers to you.

Which one should I pick?

MethodContractor joinsYou getYou give up
Competitive bidAfter drawings are finishedCompeting prices on one setEarly pricing and contractor input
NegotiatedEarly, on qualificationsBudget control during designThe head-to-head number
Design-assistDuring designPricing and advice as you drawCompeting numbers on the whole building

If you are not sure, an initial budget helps. We prepare one at no charge, as an early range and not an estimate. Contact us and tell us where your drawings are.

All articles

Common questions

Is a competitive bid always the cheapest way to hire a contractor?

Not always. A bid gives you head-to-head pricing on one set of drawings, but the contractor has no input during design, and gaps in the drawings can turn into change orders later. Compare what each bid includes, not only the total.

What is design-assist?

You hire the architect, and the contractor joins during design to price the work and advise on systems and constructability. The budget and the drawings stay in step while the building is designed.

Does Structures and Interiors do design-build?

No. We work with the owner's architect, so the architect works for the owner and not for us. For owners who want what design-build offers, one team and early pricing, we recommend design-assist, which provides nearly the same thing.

When should I bring a contractor in?

Earlier is usually better when your budget is firm or your schedule is tight. If you want competing bids, wait until the drawings are finished. Either way, an initial budget before design starts helps.

Planning a new building, a finish-out, or a renovation? Tell us about it.

Start a project817-329-4241